Why do items like this even have a chance to fail?

[aruchan 413]

 

 

I mean why? Like literally why? What is the rational behind having a fail chance for items like this? Socket Filler doesn't have a fail chance. Why does this have one?

Edited June 28, 2022 by aruchan

[Hawaii2 628]

I'm wondering why also. Materials is getting more and more pricey each day and a lot of efforts to collect them.

Upgrade donate = socket gone can't bring over. ( need extract gems out as well ) 2nd socket will be gone as well.

Extender Drill is another expensive one in game. I think we really have to work this out. Nothing comes easy i understand.

But this project is getting way too expensive.

[aruchan 413]

3 minutes ago, Hawaii2 said:

I'm wondering why also. Materials is getting more and more pricey each day and a lot of efforts to collect them.

Upgrade donate = socket gone can't bring over. ( need extract gems out as well ) 2nd socket will be gone as well.

Extender Drill is another expensive one in game. I think we really have to work this out. Nothing comes easy i understand.

But this project is getting way too expensive.

Yes. People are selling their old and weaker gear with Penta gems in their extended socket. Its cheaper to sell it as a whole than to remove the gem and reuse it on your next weapon. Its already so god damn expensive to play around with sockets. I really don't see why there is any chance to fail when making socketing tools. Excluding Extender drill of course. Making drills, Gem extractor and socket filler should all be 100%. It simply doesnt make any sense at all why theres even a 1% chance to fail. Not to mention 19%?!?!

[Keshy 1,393]

8 minutes ago, Hawaii2 said:

I'm wondering why also. Materials is getting more and more pricey each day and a lot of efforts to collect them.

Upgrade donate = socket gone can't bring over. ( need extract gems out as well ) 2nd socket will be gone as well.

Extender Drill is another expensive one in game. I think we really have to work this out. Nothing comes easy i understand.

But this project is getting way too expensive.

the worst is you spend 7kc to make an extended to put a gem that gives +15 (plus 6kc depending on the gem) to gain +15 atk

 

 

[aruchan 413]

10 minutes ago, Keshy said:

the worst is you spend 7kc to make an extended to put a gem that gives +15 (plus 6kc depending on the gem) to gain +15 atk

 

 

well 7kc if you are incredibly lucky. Rolling extender is astronomically expensive. Its out of touch for most free to play players. Even for donators its still incredibly expensive. 
I just don't get why those tools have a fail chance. Like what @Hawaii2 has said, materials are going up and its really pricey and time consuming to gather them. And now we are getting cucked by fail chance that is relatively high. Like we are already paying for the materials and all of those when crafted are gone from the game. The gold and item sink is there and yet it has a chance to fail???? Like why really? 

 

GM punishing me? what a joke lmao.

[Hawaii2 628]

Lets do a fast calculation.

Step 1;

1st socket drill = 1kc 

1st gem = 1kc to 15kc ( Emerald, Amethyst, Topaz, Aqua, Ruby ) Pentagon.

2nd extender drill = 15kc 

Mode of getting socket u want = 16.66% - 20% ( If you lucky to get Prismatic )

2nd gem = 1kc to 15kc ( Emerald, Amethyst, Topaz, Aqua, Ruby ) Pentagon

 

If you want to upgrade 140 to 144 or even 148 please repeat step 1 again.

Before repeating u will need Gem Extractor = 1kc ( Extract 1st socket +15 pentagon )

the 2nd slot gem have to give up due to too expensive to extract. ( need another extender drill ) 

 

This kind of project would easily cost u 50-100kc or even 100kc - 200kc if you repeat up to 146-148 items.

This is just a calculation for players that planning to socket your items.

 

 

 

 

Edited June 29, 2022 by Hawaii2

[moobie1988 1,235]

I believe it was designed not to be easy. Because 15 additional stats is a lot.  Even more 30 stats. This items I believe are end game items designed for Highlevels you can still benefit from using lower gems for lower levels because its cheap to make random drills now. But of course if you want to place +15 gems on end game items you would need to grind and hunt or buy from someone who is lucky enough to get it.

Fail rate is also used to avoid over stocking of materials in the server. Also it adds a bit of challenge for the game. Similar to aging.

 

 

Having a +15 str Gem and being able to move it is not really expensive because you only need 4 in reality and you just move it. Once everybody has got 4 +15 ruby gems. It would be worthless and that is the unevitable truth.

Edited June 29, 2022 by moobie1988

[Hawaii2 628]

6 minutes ago, moobie1988 said:

I believe it was designed not to be easy. Because 15 additional stats is a lot.  Even more 30 stats. This items I believe are end game items designed for Highlevels you can still benefit from using lower gems for lower levels because its cheap to make random drills now. But of course if you want to place +15 gems on end game items you would need to grind and hunt or buy from someone who is lucky enough to get it.

Nah I'm not trying to ask them to make it easy. ( maybe better if pay a fee to keep the sockets when upgrading ) will be a better option.

I'm just doing a fast calculation for players.

[moobie1988 1,235]

Just now, Hawaii2 said:

Nah I'm not trying to ask them to make it easy. ( maybe better if pay a fee to keep the sockets when upgrading ) will be a better option.

I'm just doing a fast calculation for players.

If they would allow this. We will have an excess amount of materials to create drills and fillers making it cheaper. It would be so convenient if they would just allow you to pay and you would be able to keep your sockets but you would lose a lot of fun in doing this.

 

Similar to purchasing a +24 item. No more risk Of heart aches and broken dreams.

[Hawaii2 628]

2 hours ago, moobie1988 said:

Having a +15 str Gem and being able to move it is not really expensive because you only need 4 in reality and you just move it. Once everybody has got 4 +15 ruby gems. It would be worthless and that is the unevitable truth.

 

I don't think you understand what I'm trying to say.

Most people will give up extracting their 2nd socket gem ( +15 Pentagon )

because its way too expensive than the Pentagon itself.

 

 

81% success chance for Extended Gem Extractor.

Materials needed to craft around 1.5kc + 15kc Extender Drill.

 

Will you extract out your Pentagon for example; Aqua / Ame if you have to spend like 16-18kc before extracting it out?

Doesn't make sense right?

 

 

 

 

Edited June 29, 2022 by Hawaii2

[Lyseria 1,875]

I remember I started this thread a while ago, but for different reasons. I see no problem for the failure chance, but the price. Staff is applying a heavy hand on requirements and grinding level on their releases, ofc ppl will participate even in the craziest situation, but if you stop and think about it you can see that it's...just crazy LOL.

 

https://wartale.com/forums/topic/138397-gem-extractor/

[Hawaii2 628]

3 minutes ago, Lyseria said:

I remember I started this thread a while ago, but for different reasons. I see no problem for the failure chance, but the price. Staff is applying a heavy hand on requirements and grinding level on their releases, ofc ppl will participate even in the craziest situation, but if you stop and think about it you can see that it's...just crazy LOL.

 

https://wartale.com/forums/topic/138397-gem-extractor/

Yes Dudu, i totally agree with you.

Price and materials needed is way too high.

The Extender Gem Extractor is really insane. 

You will need another 15kc + 1.5kc Materials just to extract the gem. 

[whunter 206]

+1

Edited June 29, 2022 by whunter

[moobie1988 1,235]

4 hours ago, Hawaii2 said:

 

I don't think you understand what I'm trying to say.

Most people will give up extracting their 2nd socket gem ( +15 Pentagon )

because its way too expensive than the Pentagon itself.

 

 

81% success chance for Extended Gem Extractor.

Materials needed to craft around 1.5kc + 15kc Extender Drill.

 

Will you extract out your Pentagon for example; Aqua / Ame if you have to spend like 16-18kc before extracting it out?

Doesn't make sense right?

 

 

 

 

 

Well lets not forget that all items can be looted ingame people who decides to buy from people who sell for a high price is also the ones that create demand and sets the price for this expensive items. If people buy then thats the price. If noone buys price will fall due too supply.

 

I understand what you mean. My example was str because thats the highest and most priced gem due to demand but if you look at emerald and amethyst creating +15 for both gems is cheaper than extracting them. So it shows that you are sometimes better off just making a new +15 if you use those gems.

 

Like I said if you cant afford what people sell dont buy it. They will bring the price down if noone buys. GMs have no control on how people sell items they can only tamper with more on the drop rate if they increase the chance of creating this items its the same as increasing the drop rate of the needed items creating a crash on supply. Hope it makes sense.

[Hawaii2 628]

1 minute ago, moobie1988 said:

 

Well lets not forget that all items can be looted ingame people who decides to buy from people who sell for a high price is also the ones that create demand and sets the price for this expensive items. If people buy then thats the price. If noone buys price will fall due too supply.

 

I understand what you mean. My example was str because thats the highest and most priced gem due to demand but if you look at emerald and amethyst creating +15 for both gems is cheaper than extracting them. So it shows that you are sometimes better off just making a new +15 if you use those gems.

 

Like I said if you cant afford what people sell dont buy it. They will bring the price down if noone buys. GMs have no control on how people sell items they can only tamper with more on the drop rate if they increase the chance of creating this items its the same as increasing the drop rate of the needed items creating a crash on supply. Hope it makes sense.

Sorry to say but it seems like you are not answering anything.

You turn one big round explaining nothing.

[aruchan 413]

33 minutes ago, moobie1988 said:

 

Well lets not forget that all items can be looted ingame people who decides to buy from people who sell for a high price is also the ones that create demand and sets the price for this expensive items. If people buy then thats the price. If noone buys price will fall due too supply.

 

I understand what you mean. My example was str because thats the highest and most priced gem due to demand but if you look at emerald and amethyst creating +15 for both gems is cheaper than extracting them. So it shows that you are sometimes better off just making a new +15 if you use those gems.

 

Like I said if you cant afford what people sell dont buy it. They will bring the price down if noone buys. GMs have no control on how people sell items they can only tamper with more on the drop rate if they increase the chance of creating this items its the same as increasing the drop rate of the needed items creating a crash on supply. Hope it makes sense.

You are not getting the picture. 

 

What he was trying to say is it is expensive to extract additional socket gems and on top of that, there is a chance to fail when crafting the extractor. This is not a 'if you cant afford then dont buy' situation. Even people who donate thousands of euros every month wouldn't do this too. @Lyseria's suggestion was good. Right now people wait till they get Pentagon gems before slotting it in due to the cost of removing. By reducing the cost, it will encourage players who could not afford +15 to slot their lower tier gems into the socket too. Its just stupid to make it so expensive and still have pretty high fail chance. I suggest pick either one. Make it cheaper with fail chance or make it what the current required materials with no fail chance. Either solution would result in the materials and gold erased from the economy anyway. 

Edited June 29, 2022 by aruchan

[moobie1988 1,235]

32 minutes ago, Hawaii2 said:

Sorry to say but it seems like you are not answering anything.

You turn one big round explaining nothing.

 

I answered your question their you just probably not see it:

34 minutes ago, moobie1988 said:

I understand what you mean. My example was str because thats the highest and most priced gem due to demand but if you look at emerald and amethyst creating +15 for both gems is cheaper than extracting them. So it shows that you are sometimes better off just making a new +15 if you use those gems.

Answer:  I would say No if your using cheap Gems your better off making a new +15 Gem.

 

And your Question with:

5 hours ago, Hawaii2 said:

Will you extract out your Pentagon for example; Aqua / Ame if you have to spend like 16-18kc before extracting it out?

Doesn't make sense right?

Answer:  I would Say Yes if you Value those Gems and NO if you can just make it again easily.  You are placing too much value on items that are purchased. Like I said you can loot those items so you dont need to spend anything but your time and effort. We are lucky they added a Extractor if it were like relics then this topic would be asking for a Extractor regardless if it was expensive or not.

8 minutes ago, aruchan said:

You are not getting the picture. 

 

What he was trying to say is it is expensive to extract additional socket gems and on top of that, there is a chance to fail when crafting the extractor. This is not a 'if you cant afford then dont buy' situation. Even people who donate thousands of euros every month wouldn't do this too. @Lyseria's suggestion was good. Right now people wait till they get Pentagon gems before slotting it in due to the cost of removing. By reducing the cost, it will encourage players who could not afford +15 to slot their lower tier gems into the socket too. Its just stupid to make it so expensive and still have pretty high fail chance. I suggest pick either one. Make it cheaper with fail chance or make it what the current required materials with no fail chance. Either solution would result in the materials and gold erased from the economy anyway. 

 

 

I can see where the people are having a hardtime here its the Extender Drill. Because it is difficult to acquire people are moaning for filler, drilling, extracting but the main reason is. If you can make crafting extender drill % higher then some people might not moan anymore. Because it is the main recipe you can slot in whatever Gem you want and extract it easily, Change the wrong socket to your desired one and just drill all the items you want.

 

But as the game is already too easy and players are spoiled I will just speak for those who like to have the challenge -1. But that is just my opinion.

 

Edited June 29, 2022 by moobie1988

[aruchan 413]

35 minutes ago, moobie1988 said:

 

I answered your question their you just probably not see it:

Answer:  I would say No if your using cheap Gems your better off making a new +15 Gem.

 

And your Question with:

Answer:  I would Say Yes if you Value those Gems and NO if you can just make it again easily.  You are placing too much value on items that are purchased. Like I said you can loot those items so you dont need to spend anything but your time and effort. We are lucky they added a Extractor if it were like relics then this topic would be asking for a Extractor regardless if it was expensive or not.

 

 

I can see where the people are having a hardtime here its the Extender Drill. Because it is difficult to acquire people are moaning for filler, drilling, extracting but the main reason is. If you can make crafting extender drill % higher then some people might not moan anymore. Because it is the main recipe you can slot in whatever Gem you want and extract it easily, Change the wrong socket to your desired one and just drill all the items you want.

 

But as the game is already too easy and players are spoiled I will just speak for those who like to have the challenge -1. But that is just my opinion.

 

I'll just reply to your last line. 

If you actually want a challenge you wouldn't be playing a game where you can literally spend irl money for progression and for the end game.

Edited June 29, 2022 by aruchan

[moobie1988 1,235]

10 minutes ago, aruchan said:

I'll just reply to your last line. 

If you actually want a challenge you wouldn't be playing a game where you can literally spend irl money for progression and for the end game.

 

Like I said it was my opinion on the topic and I do understand people think otherwise. I have no right to tell people how they want to play the game. I just don't think that the game is unfair when everything can be gained without spending any. I would have to disagree with your last reply. Even if a game has an option for you to spend irl money for progression for the end game it doesn't mean you have to use it. Like I said this server is well balanced that their is value to both Gold and Coins. You can get coins in this game without spending real money if you know how to. If you don't know that then maybe you don't know this server at all.

Edited June 29, 2022 by moobie1988

[Hawaii2 628]

6 hours ago, moobie1988 said:

 

Like I said it was my opinion on the topic and I do understand people think otherwise. I have no right to tell people how they want to play the game. I just don't think that the game is unfair when everything can be gained without spending any. I would have to disagree with your last reply. Even if a game has an option for you to spend irl money for progression for the end game it doesn't mean you have to use it. Like I said this server is well balanced that their is value to both Gold and Coins. You can get coins in this game without spending real money if you know how to. If you don't know that then maybe you don't know this server at all.

There is many ways of making coins / gold. 

We are just sharing on the cost of doing all this sockets thingy and not asking for +1.