rookle 218 Posted November 6 We all already know that the roll is a huge issue and, as the staff itself puts it, BEYOND HUMAN COMPREHENSION. But enough is enough—the same guy (Chimto) pulled the exact same Centlon rf C twice in two weeks! On top of that, 2 days ago, Yahuu also pulled another cent rf C, and as he said himself, it's not the first one he's gotten. What is going on? 3 1 Share this post Link to post
lordbowie 312 Posted November 6 It seems like the staff doesn't care, my friend. There have already been xx topics created about this and the problem is only getting worse. 1 Share this post Link to post
sansiro 208 Posted November 6 Well. If many people find it unfair, it's best to revert to the old method. The boss drops items, and whoever is quickest gets to grab them. No more arguing. Share this post Link to post
Support 6,052 Posted November 6 Hello, People choose to believe what they want, so no response we provide can change that. If you would like to suggest reverting to the old system, where players can simply loot items from the floor, please post your idea on the Suggestion Board so our Dev Team can consider it. Best Regards, Support Team 1 1 7 Share this post Link to post
kakalouis 1 Posted November 6 Big[Colour]**** clan also won all the valueable items. Share this post Link to post
Dior 730 Posted November 6 6 hours ago, Support said: Hello, People choose to believe what they want, so no response we provide can change that. If you would like to suggest reverting to the old system, where players can simply loot items from the floor, please post your idea on the Suggestion Board so our Dev Team can consider it. Best Regards, Support Team definitely better than this "lotto" so called system when same people win all over again. Share this post Link to post
Neither 234 Posted November 6 1 hour ago, Dior said: definitely better than this "lotto" so called system when same people win all over again. You remember nothing about old days when drops fall in the floor. 15+ players with autoclick literraly SCANNING the floor and pick up everything in 0.001ms. Players with 100+ping have no change to catch drops. The team should come up with a better solution, not us playes who has to tell what Team should do. In the past we were usually consulted with a Pool of options, and we could chose wheter systems was going to be implemented. Why dont we pool again with 4+ solutions and let the community choose. 1 - Current rool ( random in a pool of numbers ) 2 - Highest number wins ( older one ) 3 - Floor drops (user from far from server always suffer, also mules will never pickup anything) 4 - Pety system, wheter the user gains and adittional chance when losing a roulette and lose all the change when gains. (user must click 'roll') 5 - Ticket system, like HG but for bosses ( could be a box and more than 1 relic could be dropped in 1 boss for example, this would need transparency as well ) 5 - ( teams suggestions ) examples - A big french roullete with players numbers and a ball roll out till winner - A roll competition wheter players compete against one another on rools till 1 person wins Share this post Link to post
Dior 730 Posted November 6 14 minutes ago, Neither said: You remember nothing about old days when drops fall in the floor. 15+ players with autoclick literraly SCANNING the floor and pick up everything in 0.001ms. Players with 100+ping have no change to catch drops. The team should come up with a better solution, not us playes who has to tell what Team should do. In the past we were usually consulted with a Pool of options, and we could chose wheter systems was going to be implemented. Why dont we pool again with 4+ solutions and let the community choose. 1 - Current rool ( random in a pool of numbers ) 2 - Highest number wins ( older one ) 3 - Floor drops (user from far from server always suffer, also mules will never pickup anything) 4 - Pety system, wheter the user gains and adittional chance when losing a roulette and lose all the change when gains. (user must click 'roll') 5 - Ticket system, like HG but for bosses ( could be a box and more than 1 relic could be dropped in 1 boss for example, this would need transparency as well ) 5 - ( teams suggestions ) examples - A big french roullete with players numbers and a ball roll out till winner - A roll competition wheter players compete against one another on rools till 1 person wins i can tell you that.. back when i was 10x, "most" of the money i made was via looting valento rings, when they had high value. at that "era" people had to be 100% focused at the boss, and not like today, creating mules using VM and just creating PRS full health to make enough dmg to enter the poll. so at least when it is looting, people are 100% focused and cannot loot with multip accounts and only with ONE account. there is no such thing as Auto loot, and if any GM can confirm or show me that am wrong, i would like to see. just see how bad centlon and uppruni hunting looks now people from poor countries creating noob prs, and winning RF's selling them RMT, and thats how they control the market, and casual players have no other options than donating for coins to progress in game for high value items, that's why "RMT" is "good" for the server. if staff really wanted to stop that, they could do that very easy with high value items. anyways, there is a lot of abusers now, at least when it was loot, you had to learn how to loot good. i never checked how it works on other games, it is pretty interesting... 1 Share this post Link to post
Neither 234 Posted November 6 Spoiler 1 minute ago, Dior said: i can tell you that.. back when i was 10x, "most" of the money i made was via looting valento rings, when they had high value. at that "era" people had to be 100% focused at the boss, and not like today, creating mules using VM and just creating PRS full health to make enough dmg to enter the poll. so at least when it is looting, people are 100% focused and cannot loot with multip accounts and only with ONE account. there is no such thing as Auto loot, and if any GM can confirm or show me that am wrong, i would like to see. just see how bad centlon and uppruni hunting looks now people from poor countries creating noob prs, and winning RF's selling them RMT, and thats how they control the market, and casual players have no other options than donating for coins to progress in game for high value items, that's why "RMT" is "good" for the server. if staff really wanted to stop that, they could do that very easy with high value items. anyways, there is a lot of abusers now, at least when it was loot, you had to learn how to loot good. i never checked how it works on other games, it is pretty interesting... I do agree, back in the days you had 1 chance and were 100% focused on what you were doing, The part of VM is also true, today we have 50+ archers on top of each other doing boss dmg.... 1 Share this post Link to post
Dior 730 Posted November 6 Just now, Neither said: Reveal hidden contents I do agree, back in the days you had 1 chance and were 100% focused on what you were doing, The part of VM is also true, today we have 50+ archers on top of each other doing boss dmg.... Exactly.. now it is just a money laundering system. 1 1 Share this post Link to post
Dior 730 Posted November 6 and i just want to make it clear, it is not like i am againts the server or something, but everyone knows how it works, and people make living that way. im not supporting that, and also don't care who does that. Share this post Link to post
xkintaro 2,586 Posted November 6 12 hours ago, Support said: Hello, People choose to believe what they want, so no response we provide can change that. If you would like to suggest reverting to the old system, where players can simply loot items from the floor, please post your idea on the Suggestion Board so our Dev Team can consider it. Best Regards, Support Team Why not just set up a system where the highest number rolled between 1 and 10,000 wins? Everyone takes their roll, and good luck! Mathematically, the odds are the same. However, it is easier to understand and see who has won or is currently winning if a list of all rolls—along with the positions of every player within the roll system—is displayed. Share this post Link to post
Dior 730 Posted November 6 10 minutes ago, xkintaro said: Why not just set up a system where the highest number rolled between 1 and 10,000 wins? Everyone takes their roll, and good luck! Mathematically, the odds are the same. However, it is easier to understand and see who has won or is currently winning if a list of all rolls—along with the positions of every player within the roll system—is displayed. it was like that at first when roll system began, everyone saw the numbers and highest number was the winner one. they changed it, and that's what we see now.. same people winning over and over again. there is no way it is just luck, in any mathetmatical way. 1 Share this post Link to post
Itaxinhos 27 Posted November 6 I'd like to make a suggestion regarding the boss loot system. I've brought up this issue several times because, although I've reported a few bugs, this is the only thing that genuinely concerns me: the boss loot rolls. The game is good, and I really enjoy playing it. However, I think the boss reward system could benefit from an approach similar to the one used for HG bosses. For example, after completing 5 bosses in a boss rotation, or even 8–9, players would receive all scrolls ( one for boss ) that gives them a chance to obtain an item. There's no guarantee of getting something valuable, or even getting anything at all, but there's always a possibility of receiving something, whether it's a crystal, a Dagaz, or another item. I also think the current system of dropping items on the ground could be improved. Think about it: I've been playing for two years, and I've only managed to pick up coins from the ground twice. Imagine trying to pick up an actual item. Ping and latency make this even more frustrating, and they can put some players at a significant disadvantage. The number-based loot roll system is also a good idea because it gives players a sense of transparency and confidence that the reward is being distributed fairly. Of course, it's disappointing for someone who rolls a 1 or 2, because they already know they've lost, but at least the process feels more transparent. Honestly, I believe the HG system is playe efficient. Even after doing around 200 runs and receiving only 3 items (Throne), that's still something. At least there's a visible reward system and a sense that your time and effort can eventually pay off. I believe implementing something similar could make boss rotations more rewarding, fair, and enjoyable for everyone. idk why some comments are hidden Share this post Link to post
LievZor 35 Posted November 6 Maybe the Wartale team could share some general stats or Loot Lotto logs to make things a bit more transparent. Winning multiple rare items doesnt necessarily mean something is wrong. With around 50 players per roll, each has a 2% chance of winning, so someone participating in 300 rolls would win around 6 times on average. A good example is the FuNNy discussion. Not suggesting anything wrong with the player, just using it as an example of how statistics could help. If we knew how many rolls he participated in, we could mathematically estimate how likely that number of wins was. Without that information, its mostly speculation. Sharing some basic stats could help clear up doubts, avoid these discussions happening over and over again, and give players more confidence in the system. 1 Share this post Link to post
Coyote 407 Posted November 6 6 hours ago, Neither said: Reveal hidden contents I do agree, back in the days you had 1 chance and were 100% focused on what you were doing, The part of VM is also true, today we have 50+ archers on top of each other doing boss dmg.... Something I’ve noticed over the years—in every post and every comment regarding this—is the term "Virtual Machine" or "VM." My understanding was that "VMs" were not permitted in this game. So, the question arises: is the use of a Virtual Machine allowed in Wartale?... Share this post Link to post
WHATISAMAN? 177 Posted November 6 It's rare, but somehow it happens every single day. 1 1 Share this post Link to post
ik3r 1,151 Posted November 6 (edited) i think you cant win the same item twice, after you win something like a RF next time when you roll a RF you need have less chance to win .... Edited November 6 by ik3r 1 Share this post Link to post
meninayclo 229 Posted November 7 8 hours ago, Shorex said: 1 roll per IP not by device. And what about couples who play together? XD Thats good, but theres this issue 1 1 Share this post Link to post
zapas0709 2 Posted November 7 +1 vote Drop Items Boss As you are aware, the drop system includes restrictions to prevent a single user from operating multiple computers to increase their chances of obtaining items from bosses. While there may be variations in latency (ping) depending on a player's region, the fact that players in different time zones are active at different times—while others are resting—helps to balance the overall distribution. This approach ensures a much fairer outcome compared to a scenario where a user could simply log in from multiple computers to gain a significantly higher advantage over someone playing on just one machine. 1 Share this post Link to post
rookle 218 Posted November 7 4 hours ago, longpro9x said: +1 1 roll per IP not by device. aggree Share this post Link to post
Shorex 282 Posted November 7 7 hours ago, meninayclo said: And what about couples who play together? XD Thats good, but theres this issue Let them break up. 6 Share this post Link to post
aruchan 486 Posted November 8 On 11/8/2026 at 4:00 AM, rookle said: aggree Could easily bypass by setting each client with a different IP bia VPNs though. 1 Share this post Link to post